Muscle Today한국어
On this page
  1. How much muscle response varies between people
  2. Does changing the weight make a difference?
  3. What happened when sets increased
  4. What to try when muscle comes slowly
  5. What these studies leave out
  6. References

ArticlesNutrition

Can Skinny Hardgainers Really Not Build Muscle?

Published 2026-11-093 sources3 min read

Back view of a person gripping a barbell before a set in a sunlit gym

Short answer: No. While individual responses may be slow, a study in older adults showed that some who had no response to 1 set grew with 4 sets, though others did not respond even with 4 sets. In addition, changing weights (between 10RM and 15RM) did not meaningfully change responsiveness.

How much muscle response varies between people

Untrained healthy men and women aged 19 to 78 (287 participants, including 72 controls) were pooled to track training adaptations. Muscle size changed by an average of 4.8 ± 6.1%, with individual outcomes ranging widely from -11% to 30%. Strength changed by 21.1 ± 11.5%, ranging from -8% to 60%. When evaluated against non-training controls, 29% were classified as low responders for muscle size and 7% for strength, while 14% were high responders for muscle size. Age and sex did not affect these training responses[1].

Nearly three in ten lifters may see slow changes in muscle size on standard programs. Slower progress is part of normal human variability rather than a permanent limitation. To support weight gain, check your overall intake with how to lean bulk.

Does changing the weight make a difference?

Twenty-seven older women (average age 67.7 ± 4.9 years) completed two 8-week routines using 15RM and 10RM in a crossover design, separated by a 12-week detraining period. DXA-estimated skeletal muscle mass increased by 0.62 ± 0.4 kg in the 15RM condition and 0.43 ± 0.3 kg in the 10RM condition, with no meaningful difference between the two loads. While 61.1% responded in at least one condition, 25.9% were non-responders in both. Shifting between 10RM and 15RM changed responsiveness status in only seven participants (25.9%)[2].

Simply swapping a slightly heavier weight for a lighter one is unlikely to wake up stubborn muscle growth on its own.

What happened when sets increased

In a study examining the effects of set volume, 27 older adults (average age 69 ± 3 years) trained one leg with 1 set and the opposite leg with 4 sets, twice a week for 10 weeks. Participants who showed minimal muscle growth from 1 set (medium responders) were able to offset nonresponsiveness when training with 4 sets. On the other hand, low responders showed little muscle growth whether they trained with 1 set or 4 sets. Quadriceps muscle cross-sectional area was higher with 4 sets than with 1 set in both medium and high responders[3].

Rather than shifting weights between 10RM and 15RM, increasing sets helped some individuals respond. However, this was not true for everyone.

What to try when muscle comes slowly

  • Move from 1 set to 4 sets per muscle (per leg). If progress is minimal with 1 set on key lower-body exercises, build up to 4 sets twice a week to ensure adequate total training volume[3].
  • Pick either 10RM or 15RM loads. Both loading ranges increased muscle mass without clear differences, so choose a load you can execute consistently across your target sets[2].
  • Stay consistent for 8 to 10 weeks. The study durations were 8 to 10 weeks, as seen in the twice-weekly 10-week Lixandrao trial or the 8-week Ribeiro study[3][2].

Pairing higher set counts with sufficient daily nutrition also matters. See how much protein you need per day to support your training.

What these studies leave out

The 2016 cohort of 287 participants was an after-the-fact pooling of multiple distinct studies rather than a single uniform trial[1]. Furthermore, the 2025 and 2026 trials tested small groups of 27 older adults (aged 69 and 67.7 years) over relatively brief 8- to 10-week interventions[3][2]. In addition, the Lixandrao trial was a unilateral study confined to the quadriceps rather than the whole body and low responders showed little muscle growth even with increased volume, while the Ribeiro trial was limited to 67.7-year-old older women and evaluated muscle mass via DXA estimates. They did not directly measure young skinny adults or track outcomes over several months or years.

Instead of assuming you cannot build muscle, treat these findings as a practical benchmark: try increasing your sets toward 4 sets per muscle before deciding your body will not respond.

How Muscle Today helps. Muscle Today focuses on the basics that matter most — your sets, recovery for 34 muscles, protein, and sleep — and every number links to its sources.

This article is general information for healthy adults and is not medical advice. If you have a medical condition or health concerns, consult a qualified professional before changing your training routine.

References

  1. Ahtiainen et al. (2016) Heterogeneity in resistance training-induced muscle strength and mass responses in men and women of different ages.. Age (Dordr) PubMed
  2. Ribeiro et al. (2026) Responsiveness of muscle mass gain to different load intensities of resistance training in older women: A randomized crossover study.. Exp Gerontol PubMed
  3. Lixandrao et al. (2025) Molecular signatures underlying heterogenous hypertrophy responsiveness to resistance training in older men and women: a within-subject design.. J Appl Physiol (1985) PubMed